Agenda - Planning Commission - 04/07/2005

Home

Z.B. ~ i .~ ;: j /; ? March 10, 2005 -- Page 5 Subdivision -- bio reCOil e~ 6fi~es~ction on property Board bases denial on¢e°p~ii's ~a~'es : · Citation: ~intz v. ToW~hip ;ofi.M/tllto~q, Superior Court of New Jersey, App. oiv., Nos. A.J ~xV.OSr~ ~'A~2~i-V~J~ (2005) . NEW IERSEY (01/2~/~5)~n~!~ught to subdivide 'rs lot. ~s lot had ohginally been subdivi~d' ~ ' ~ "-~---~ ~ ;~ }1 ~ ~;ts from a l~ger ~act in 1980. ~e city plan~ng b~a{dSm¢~z's'r~qu~st.rt found Mintz's property was restdcte~ from ~er&Ub~{id~k~t~rthe odginai 1980 subdivision. The bo~d based ~ts dems~fl on: ~e~d~al ~ewdence, ~nctud~n, the memories of mdt v~duals as to wha~ ~eg:be~v~04cu~ed when the subdivision applica- tion was granted in 198~. ~ ~' ~ '~ ' · Mintz sued, and th~Zou~ ml~d~ ~s favor. ' ~e to'wns~p applied, ~gd~[~ople remembered that each of the 12 subdivided lots w~ i~t~ded [o:f~al~ ~s a ~k-acre ~ett~. ... 1: ~ ~ .... In the absence of ~y wnt~O~r~abl~ memon~zed the creation o~ the . . ~ ~ "~ FZ~ ~ ~ · ' · · .- alleged restnctton, the~o~d's ra~g ~ ~b~, capncmus,.and u~eason- able. '~ : ~, ~ None of the p~ies}Were :abl~:. ~ ~t0 lo'rte either a deed restriction precluding subdivision of the 12 1~; a ~o~y¢Of;:~e sUbdivision map, or a copy of the resolution grating m~ ~ubmv.iS~off, ~:~ ~ - ' If it were ~sumed :~at the'¢Bo~ ~0~any indicated in 1980 ~at subdivision approval was: conditiO~d 0n~re~e~n 6n:~y ~her subdivision, the bo~d never tssueda resolu~n, :~$o,~n~ sg~dtwsmn map w~ ever filed wx~ ~e approphate c°un~ officen : ~¢ ': ~ ~} ~ ~ ' Even ff M~n~z had ~d a ~mo~ab~t ~ un-memona~zed and un-recorded restriction on'rs pr~r~w~n~h~ b~ght tt, such rumor did not balance out the h~dship Mintz W~ld suffe~:~ a ~r~sult of e~orcement of the ~leged re- sthction. ~PonantlY,~¢ would l~}~ beaefit of Us contract ~d ownershp, i.e., subdividable.prop~. ~ :' ~ :: ~:: ~ . Ultimately, thebo~a co~ta:%t'~f&~m~ alleged restriction ag~nst Mintz b~ed on people's meshes. ~ : :: see also: Island Venmr~sS°c~at¢s ~.N~ jersey Deparment of Environnzental Protection, 846 A.2d:~228: see also: Cox v. R~ CorPorht~on~ ~75~ A.2d 1112 r2000). Si~ -- B~e~ o~gr par~ t~er~4n property ~ Ueu of ord~a~ silage TrailerPlaced within ~equir~ ~ ~tha~s for stgns*~ ~ : '~ ' Citation: Sn~e v. Jac~n T°ms~i~B~4rd of Zoning Appeals, Court of Appeals of Ohio, 5th App. Dis~.~ stark ~o~,,~No. :2004CA00127 (2005)'. OHIO (01/18/05) ~ 8Cee: omneg-Eartg n Wood. Earth n Wood placed a box ~ 2005 Qutnlan Publ~sh~ng Groq~. Any:ra~t~c~?s:pfo~blt~. For more m/ormal~on please call (617) 542-0048. 151